Skip to main content

The Missing NLP Paper Guide, written by Shamsuddeen Hassan Muhammad

The Missing NLP Paper Guide

The class nobody teaches you: how to write your first paper for ACL, EMNLP, NAACL, EACL, and the rest of the *ACL family.


Why this exists​

Your PhD program does not teach you how to write a paper. Your advisor assumes you picked it up by osmosis. Your peers pretend they already know how. The official ACL author guidelines cover the format of a paper: margins, citation style, page limits. They say nothing about the craft. They will not show you how to frame a contribution, or what a related work section needs beyond a list of citations. Nor will they explain why your introduction feels flat, or why a reviewer called your results section "hard to follow" when the numbers are right there.

This guide is that missing class. MIT's Missing Semester of Your CS Education taught students the command line, version control, and debugging tools that nobody had bothered to teach them. We try to do the same for *ACL paper writing, as the methods seminar your program never ran.

Who this is for​

  • First-time *ACL authors: PhD students, MS students, or industry researchers with a result and a deadline.
  • Advisors who want a single artifact to hand new students instead of explaining the same things every cycle.
  • Reading groups running a "how to write papers" session.

If you have published five or more first-author *ACL papers, this guide is probably below your level. We would still love your contributions.

What you get​

  • 31 chapters covering every section of an *ACL paper, plus where to publish, collaboration, figures, rebuttals, reviewing, and what to do after the decision.
  • Five examples from real ACL/EMNLP/NAACL papers in each chapter. None are invented.
  • A phrasebook of rhetorical moves in each chapter: verbatim openings, pivots, and closings from highly-cited NLP papers. We group them by the job they do (context, gap, proposal, method, result, implication). The idea comes from the Manchester Academic Phrasebook, but our phrases follow *ACL conventions and come from real papers instead of generic academic English.
  • A printable one-page submission checklist.
  • A papers-to-read.bib with every paper cited in Chapter 30, ready to drop into Overleaf.
  • A structured examples database you can browse by section or by paper.

What this is not​

  • It is not the official ACL author guidelines. For format, page limits, anonymity rules, and the Responsible NLP Checklist, see the ACL Rolling Review CFP and the ACLPUB formatting page. When the official guidelines and this guide disagree, the official guidelines win.
  • It is not AI-generated filler. Every example links to a real paper on the ACL Anthology.
  • It is not a substitute for reading great papers. Chapter 30 tells you which ones.

How to use it​

Pick the track that matches your situation.

Your situationRead these chapters
Speed run (deadline in 2 weeks, paper mostly drafted)12 Abstract, 13 Introduction, 19 Results, 22 Limitations, 31 Checklist
First paper (you have 6–8 weeks)All chapters, in order
First-timer to NLP (deciding where to submit)1 Publication Landscape, 2 Understanding the Field, 4 Contribution, 6 Framing, 30 Best Papers
Studying the craft (no deadline, want to get better)2 Understanding the Field, 4 Contribution, 6 Framing, 30 Best Papers, then any chapter that scratches an itch
Reviewing, not writing27 How to Review Well, 20 Analysis, 22 Limitations, 30 Best Papers

Chapters​

  1. The NLP Publication Landscape
  2. Understanding the Field
  3. What Kind of Paper Are You Writing?
  4. What Counts as a Contribution?
  5. Decoding the Jargon
  6. Before You Write
  7. Working With Advisors and Co-authors
  8. Writing Clearly
  9. Figures and Tables That Work
  10. The Structure of an *ACL Paper
  11. The Title
  12. The Abstract
  13. The Introduction
  14. Related Work
  15. Background / Preliminaries
  16. Dataset Construction
  17. Methods
  18. Experimental Setup
  19. Results
  20. Analysis and Discussion
  21. Conclusion
  22. Limitations (Required)
  23. Ethical Considerations
  24. Using AI Tools Responsibly
  25. References & Appendices
  26. The Rebuttal
  27. How to Review Well
  28. After Rejection
  29. After Acceptance
  30. Best Papers Worth Reading
  31. A Final Checklist

Contributing​

Yes, please. The guide improves each time an experienced author shares what they have learned. See CONTRIBUTING.md in the repo.

License​

CC BY 4.0. Use it, fork it, translate it, hand it to your students. Attribution appreciated.